These guys are back to their old tricks


Quite the prank on us. The Archdiocese of Agana managed for five decades to systematically allow priests, teachers, and other lay officials to rape boys and girls under their care, then cover it all up. That cover-up came by way of false prophecy, shame, threats, and even the brainwashing of parents and grandparents against their children and grandchildren. Not the work of Christ or His Church, to say the least.

Then, when it all came out midway through the last decade, this same group of men that for all these years condescended to us faithful to live by truth and light and to turn away from injustice DID NOT say they were sorry for what should have been a racketeer influenced and corrupt organization (RICO) case, had it not been for the statute of limits in place at the time. No. They had to be dragged into court, kicking and screaming.

They hired high-powered lawyers from Washington, D.C. who dragged out the court case for a decade, depriving the victims of meager compensation during that time and WORSE: forcing the surviving victims into depositions to relive each of their nightmares CAUSED BY THE ARCHDIOCESE.

The victims began receiving payments about two years ago, followed by apologies from Archbishop Emeritus Michael Byrnes, then Father Romeo Convocar, then Father Jeff San Nicolas at last year’s procession in honor of Santa Marian Kamalen, then by Archbishop Ryan Jimenez at his installation Mass this past summer.

There have been daily prayers for the victims of the Archdiocese. Archbishop Jimenez has promised transparency and strict vigilance to protect children within the church, its schools, and its other programs. The Archdiocese created protocols and programs, all forced upon it by Chief Judge Frances Tydingco-Gatewood of the U.S. District Court of Guam.

The dust had finally settled on the scandal. The victims were finally getting a reprieve from their nightmare; some were able to start a journey of healing.

And then the Archdiocese began to do what some suspected it would when the lawsuits ended. The Archdiocese is back to its old tricks.

A few days ago I wrote about my experience at San Juan Bautista Catholic Church in Ordot on Saturday, when a church leader there blamed the clergy sex abuse victims for the financial situation of the parish during parish announcements. I immediately emailed the archbishop, asking for an interview on the matter. I have followed up a number of times, and he hasn’t had the decency to reply at all, despite his promise made the day after his installation that he would be transparent and available to the local media.

That promise of transparency has to mean something, and there has to be a benchmark. That benchmark needs to rest on the idea that the archbishop and his curia will be open, truthful, and forthcoming about bad news. Bad news happens. Bad things happen. It is always, always, always the cover-up that turns something from bad to evil.

Weeks ago, the Archdiocese –  by order of the federal court – was supposed to have published onto its website the names of two active priests who have been accused of sexual misconduct. That disclosure never happened. I asked the archbishop in an email why the Archdiocese has not complied with the court order. He hasn’t replied.

Then today, the archbishop emailed a letter to all the priests of the Archdiocese informing them that another priest had been accused of sexual misconduct. (We received this letter from a confidential source, agreeing to redact identifying information in exchange for permission to publish it.) This letter was not released to the public. There has been no disclosure to the Catholic faithful or the general community.

Different times. Different archbishop. Same Archdiocese. Cold. Conflicted. Dishonest. And uncaring in the least about the trail of tears it has left in the wake of its struggle for power and influence.

This letter signed by the archbishop was sent only to the Catholic clergy of Guam in an email. It has not been publicly released, which is why we redacted identifying information.

1 Comments

  • CNMI Lawyer

      11/16/2024 at 5:43 PM

    Rather than “tricks”, this is another blessed step on the journey of healing.

    The Archbishop’s commitment to transparency is commendable. Providing this information first to the clergy, who certainly shouldn’t be learning about it from the press (!), is praiseworthy. The faithful will know in due course.

    Likewise, no competent attorney would advise the archbishop to respond to a press inquiry about non-compliance with a court order. The sole venue for such inquiries and responses is in court.

    Furthermore, if a member of the press were a participant in the litigation, that creates a conflict of interest such that an attorney would advise against substantive discussions of the matter with that party. This is standard advice that would be given by any lawyer. Please don’t take it personally.

    Nor, with his limited resources and demands on his time, can an archbishop drop everything and respond to each individual request. Full transparency would be fulfilled if a similar letter is released publicly. Patience is a virtue.

    Sharing an access point to the professional counseling available for the victims of this evil is a positive step.

    As Archbishop Ryan notes, he has to respect the human dignity of both the alleged perpetrator and victim, attending to both with love, mercy, and justice.

    That is why God created Purgatory, because He is infinitely just, and infinitely merciful. Sadly, here on Earth we fall short.

    It is in imputing motives to others that we are most likely to err. “Cold. Conflicted. Dishonest. Uncaring.” That is certainly not the Archbishop Ryan that I have known well since before his ordination as a priest for the Diocese of Chalan Kanoa in June 2003.

    “Judge not, lest ye be judged.”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Advertisement